LEGAL BRIEFS BY SUSAN MURRAY AND BETH ROBINSON pparently the Boy Scouts of America have decided that a scout is not only trustworthy, 7 thrifty, and brave: now a scout, and a scout leader, must be heterosexu- al. I A Tale of Two Leaders In California in 1980, the Boy Scouts rejected the application of Timothy Cunan, a former Eagle Scout who had received numerous honors throughout his scouting career, because he had publicly dis- cussed his homosexuality. Ten years later, in New Jersey, the Boy Scouts dismissed James Dale, a leader with an equally impressive roster of scouting accomplish- ments, for the same reason. Invoking state laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexu- al orientation, both former scouts sued. The California Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Boy Scouts. The New Jersey Supreme Court is still considering the issue, but the intennediate appeals court ruled in favor of the Scout leader. In analyzing these cases, the courts grappled with two questions: First, are the Boy Scouts covered by state anti-discrimination laws? Second, is it unconstitutional to require the organization to accept gay leaders? Applicability of State Laws The California Supreme Court concluded that Califomia’s anti- discrimination laws goveming “business establishments” do not apply to the Boy Scouts. The rea- soning: “The Boy Scouts is an organization whose primary func- tion is the inculcation of a specific set of values in its youth members,” and, to that end, “Scouts meet regu- larly in small groups . . . and are required to participate in a variety of activities, ceremonies, and rituals that are designed to teach the moral principles to which the organization subscribes.” The New Jersey appeals court A disagreed (although the New Jersey Supreme Court will have the last word in that case). In concluding that the Boy Scouts are a place of public accommodation under New Jersey’s anti-discrimination law, the appeals court noted that as of 1993, scouting had nearly 5 million mem- bers nationwide, and nearly 90 mil- lion boys and men have joined the Boy Scouts since 1910; that the Boy Scouts actively advertise to the public to encourage new members; and that the Boy Scout charter and bylaws emphasize inclusion of all boys who meet entrance age requirements. Given these facts, the court recognized that it would be disingenuous to treat the Boy Scouts as a truly private club. Constitutional Considerations Given its conclusion that the anti-discrimination statute did not apply, the California Supreme Court did not have to resolve the constitutional question. The New Jersey court, in contrast, had to grapple with the question of whether compelling the Boy Scouts to accept gay leaders would violate the organization’s First Amendment rights to express its opposition to homosexuality and to associate with leaders who share its views. In analyzing that question, the court considered whether applying the anti-discrimination law would interfere with the Boy Scouts’ rea- son for organizing and existing. The Court concluded that the Boy Scouts were chartered by Congress “to promote . . . the ability of boys _ to do things for themselves and oth- ers, to train them in Scoutcrafi, and to teach them patriotism, courage, self-reliance, and kindred virtues . .3‘ .” To that end, Scout leaders are expected to impart in scouts the val- ues of “trustworthiness, honesty, independence, physical and moral courage, commitment, cleanliness and fidelity.” The court concluded that apply- ing the anti-discrimination law to the scouts would not in any way impede the Boy Scouts’ ability to instill in scouts the qualities of lead- ership, courage, and integrity asso- ciated with the Boy Scouts, and rejected the Boy Scouts’ constitu- tional defense. Shattering Myths The New Jersey court went on to address the Boy Scouts’ unspo- ken fear that gay scoutrnasters would pose some sort of threat to their scouts: “There is absolutely no evidence . . . that a gay scoutmaster, solely because he is a homosexual, does not possess the strength of character necessary to properly care for, or to impart [Boy Scout] ideals to the young boys in his charge. Nothing before us even suggests that a male, simply because he is “Nothing before us even suggests that a male, simply because he is gay, will somehow undermine A [the Boy Scouts ’] fundamental beliefs and teachings. ” gay, will somehow undermine [the Boy Scouts’] fimdarnental beliefs * and teachings.” The Future The Boy Scout issue is far from resolved. Until, as one California Supreme Court justice put it, “the ideals of scouting transform its con- duct,” we can expect to see more dismissals of highly-qualified and committed gay scout leaders, and more litigation. However, the litiga- tion will likely be concentrated in the minority of states which have gay rights laws (such as Vermont), since gay men and lesbian women in most states don’t enjoy basic pro- tections against arbitrary discrimi- nation. V Susan Murray and Beth Robinson are attorneys at Langrock Sperry & Wool in Middlebury whose practices include general commercial and civil litigation, employment, family, estate, personal injury and work- ers compensation cases. If you ’d like our column to cover a particu- lar legal issue of interest to our community, please write OI TM or call us at 388-6356. BLACKWOOD ASSOCIATES, RC. ATTORNEYS AT (802) 863-2517 - fax: (302) 863-0262 L A W‘ PO. Box 875 Burlington, VT 05402 e—mail: Vtlawbk@aol.com (Located in the same space as Jerome the Florist) The ]eweler's Bench Patricia Palumbo . Custom Designer ~ jeweler Jewelry Repalrmg Fine Handcrafted Jewelry 260 North Main Street, Barre, VT 05641 ~ 802-479-1496 ll OUT IN THE ‘MOUNTAINS — FEBRUARY 1998 - 11 Good legal advice can make ll , all the difference. Langrock Sperry 8c Wool offers the services of 22 lawyers with over 300 years’ combined experience in all areas of the law ——- including two lesbian attorneys with special expertise serving the legal needs of the g/ 1/ b/ t,/ q community II Susan M. Murray C9’ Beth Robinson With offices in Middlebury and Burlington Q’ Middlebury (802) 388-6356 Burlington (802) 864-0217 E—mail: smurray@langrock.com & brobinson@langrock.com LANGROCK SPERRY & WOOL ATTORNEYS AT LAW ingsl _ Arimamrnrroi * ' SALE ;‘r‘:':,l'l‘.K.?‘«‘s'r¥.'§;§r‘i 207 FLYNN AVE. BURLINGTON, VT BY THE TRACKS &O2_56O_1m j. srorrrrwrnra Antiques, Collectibles & Uscful Th Houas: TUE5-5AT10*6. 5UN 1-5, CLOSED MONDAY THREF OLD BATS tell them you found it at ‘THAT BOOK STORE... (now on Railroad Street) USED AND ANTIQUARIAN BOOKS BUY 0 Sill. 0 TRADE USED AND OUT-OF-PRINT BOOKS ' POSTCARDS PAPER EPHEMERA 0 VT AND NH BOOKS Monday - Saturday l0:00 - 0:00, Sunday I I200 - 0:00 so Railroad srmr, St. Johslmy, Vomoat 05819 002 7484122 - Hui: meIIunmm.avms.coa I0! SIREEIEI - DAVE VIAIDEII A beautifully appointed 18905 Gingerbread Victorian with newly expanded Carriage House Suites. The Inn has recently been written about and recommended by Country Living Magazine, The Boston Phoenix, and Out magazine. In the main house, hand-picked antiques, hard wood floors, and a cozy fireplace set the relaxed mood. Our Carriage House Suites have superlative accommodations with in-room jacuzzi, fireplaces, queensize beds, and TVNCR. We're just minutes away from Jay Peak Ski Resort. Coem experience gourmet breakfasts, afternoon teas, and a refreshing attention to detail. 5’: PHINEAS SWANN gs Bed ‘n’ Breakfast Main Street 0 P.O. Box 43 Montgomery Center, Vermont 05471 802-326-4306 www.pbpub.oom/phineasswarm vt toll free: 877-557-7236 ~ email: ppalumbo@sover.net