,\d Creating CIVIL UNION Linda Esettirsgdaie Basements Sass History in words and Pictures he year was 2000, and, THinesburg author Linda Hollingdale writes in the Introduction to her new book, Creating Civil Union: Opening Hearts and Minds, she was looking for a new project to "mark and cele- brate my 30 yearsas a photogra- pher.” She also wondered, “How will I ever be able to tell my nieces (then ages 7 and 3) what [the struggle for civil union] was really like?" That combination gave rise to her project, a photo/essay exhibit and book. The exhibit of photographs is at the Flynndog Gallery (208 Flynn Ave., Burlington) from October 4 to November 9, 2002 with an opening reception on October 4, from 6 to 8 pm. The book, which Hollingdale is self-publishing as “Common Humanity Press,” will also be available this month, even though the official publication date is November 1. Hollingdale’s collection of 47 black and white photographs with companion essays documents the leg- islative struggle for the right of gay/lesbian marriage that resulted in Vermont's historic civil union law. The participants in this collection of essays had worked to create and/or support civil union, and their writings reflect some of their thoughts, feel- ings, and experiences during the process. Included are perspectives from the Baker v. State plaintiffs and attorneys, several legislators and the ‘ governor, clergy members, volun- teers, couples, parents, Justices of the Peace, town clerks, a lobbyist and a journalist. ' “Creating Civil Union puts a human face on a very controversial issue,” writes Hollingdale. “It both celebrates the amazing work of hun- dreds of citizens and serves as an invitation to readers and viewers to expand their awareness and under- standing. of this latest civil rights movement. Through the power of words and images, our common humanity is revealed.” Below is an excerpt from the book and its accompanying photo (although newsprint can rarely do justice to good photography). The words in italic are Hollingdale’s; the rest belong to Sandi and Bobbi Cote- Whitacre. Sandi and Bobbi Cote-Whitacre We almost decided not to have a civil union. This declaration may seem surprising coming from a couple who worked diligently in the fight for same-sex marriage. But Sandi and Bobbi were working for marriage, not Some reasonable facsimile, such as civil union. The Baker v. State lawsuit Was undertaken to win marriage rights for lesbian and gay couples. The Vermont Supreme Court upheld the legal basis for that right. However; rather than granting same- Sex couples the right to marry, the Court handed the job of "crafting" llle details of this right to the Vermont Legislature. The result of lhat work, civil union, was consid- ered a compromise. Sandi and Bobbi believe that the only ones who com- promised were the people who were denied their full rights. The opposi- tion to same-sex marriage didn’t compromise; they, were against same- sex marriage, they are against civil union, and they would take it away if given the chance. Even though Bobbi and Sandi understood the desire of the legislature to find relative comfort for everyone, they also knew that the price for that comfort would fall on the shoulders of the people who con- tinued to be marginalized. There comes a time in every civil rights movement when the carrot is dangled in front of the fighters, when the words “wait” and “don’t go so fast” are heard in the court of public opin- ion. The carrot of compromise was dangling in front of us, and after much soul—searching, we came to the conclusion that to reach for this car- rot would hurt not only those of us fighting for our rights now; it would condemn future generations to decades of work dismantling this compromise. History often reminds us of this dilemma. One example in 1896 was the case of Plessy v. Ferguson, in which the US. Supreme Court upheld lower court rulings that supported the “separate but equal ” racial laws. The lone dissenter was Justice John Harlan. Harlan said, “The destinies of the two races in this country are indissolubly linked together, and the interests of both require that the com- mon govemment of all shall not per- mit the seeds of hatred to be planted under the sanction of law.” Now replace “races” with “orientations.” Sandi and Bobbi see a par- allel with civil union. What can more certainly arouse hate, what can more certainly create and perpetuate a feel- ing of distrust between gays and straights. than state enactments which in fact proceed on the ground that gays and lesbians are so inferior and degraded that they cannot be allowed to marry like straights? That is the real meaning of such legislation as civil union, the thin disguise of “equal” benefits for couples in com- mitted relationships. We, as a move- ment, must continue to stay_the course; we must stay focused on the “rights” of marriage and notjust the “benefits.” Civil rights can never be decided by a plebiscite, and we can- not agree to give up our human rights without admitting we are less than human. We don’t have the right to take the immediate partial benefits that are being dangled in front of us at the expense of future generations. Nevertheless, on July 1, 2000, the civil union bill became law. The paradoxical nature of this law leaves many Vermonters feeling elat- ed andyvalidated by having their relationships legally recognized, while still feeling like second-class citizens. Bobbi and Sandi hope that this compromise will encourage those who don ’t feel comfortable with same-sex marriage to take the oppor- tunity to see lesbian and gay rela- tionships in a positive light. When asked why they decided to be joined in civil union, Sandi and Bobbi smiled and looked at Betty Whitacre, Bobbi 3' 85-year- old mother; who said, “I just wanted the opportunity to see them get mar- ried. I didn't want to run out of time.” - To ensure this opportunity, Betty 3‘ support went beyond the per- sonal. Using her message, “They can’t do this to my girls,” the Vermont Freedom to Marry Task Force sent out a fundraising letter that brought in thousands of dollars. Betty understands the concerns of Bobbi and Sandi, because as a very religious person she wanted them to marry in a church. And even though their civil union was not full-fledged marriage, she was proud to say that there were three ministers at Bobbi and Sandi Is‘ ceremony. She is grateful to have witnessed her daughter and ' daughter-in-law is wedding -— so much so, that she celebrated by dancing with “her girls " at their reception! V Linda Hollingdale lives in Hinesburg. We’ll Help Pick Everything Else ’ve spent what seems like a lifetime waiting for this day. And wh comes time to register, help your family and friends choose the gi that will enhance every room in your home for years to come. The‘ " . Store in Waitsfield offers Vermont’s premier selection of gifts that dulge bed, bath, kitchen, body, and soul. Cookware from All-Clad Calphalon, and La Creusett. Cutlery from Wtisthof. . Kitchen accessories from Cuisinart. And a wide range of linens, serving pieces, antiques, and pottery. We can even help you choose the perfect gift for your attendants. I ut we can do more than help your guests select the perfect gifts. we help you as well, with a wedding consultant who can assist you in choos- ing everything from invitations and flowers to a caterer and photogra- pher. Best of all, in addition to accepting all major credit cards, we’re also happy to accept all unions endorsed by the State ofVermont. All the personal attention you deserve is just a phone call away. Why not contact the professionals at our Wedding Registry today? Start put- ting finishing touches on the day you started dreaming about years ago. The World Comes to Waitsfield The Store has everything you could imagine, yet it’s like nothing you’ve ever seen. It’s shopping for the truly adventurous, offering a wellspring of delights for the kitchen, bathroom, palate, and imagination. The Setting The Store is located in a carefully restored, two-story 1834 Methodist Meeting House. In fact, the only thing more exquisite than our eclectic mix of products is the fascinating ways they’re displayed. No matter ifyou are in the area or out of town, we are only a phone call away on The Store Wedding Hotline 1-800-639-8031. TH E S'l‘0l{E Route 100, Waitsfield, Vermont (802) 496-4465 FAX (802) 496-7719 Est. 1965 Open 10-6 Daily Email - info@vennontstore.com Web Site - www.vermontstore.com www. Your new Vermont home.com 1 Oops, no spaces! Polly Menendez MS, PT Nurturing Therapeutic Massage Physical memny Exercise Consultation Burlington VT -- call 859 0788