Embracing Your Selves REVIEW BY DAVID GRENIER I usually like to read books that I can identify with. I can’t deal with reading about breakups or gushy love stories; Conversely, if it’s provocative and swirling with sexual innu- endo, I will read it. But every now and then a title catches my eye that tweaks my desire for serious discussion or explo- ration, an oasis from the‘ hun- dreds of books out there that try and to something important but fall short. -I ' opened Daniel Mendelsohn’s The Elusive Embrace: Desire and the Riddle of Identity, expecting another drippy memoir of a distressed queen looking for love. But what I found was quite the opposite: a meticu- lously detailed, insightful, and bold attempt to answer those tough questions about gay identity most of us are afraid to confront in our own lives. Mendelsohn’s exploration of gay identity is honest and thought provoking, and I admit I found myself captivated by his story. Growing up just outside of New York City, raised by a mathematician father who envisioned every answer to life’s questions as rigid scien- tific equations, a young Daniel discovers a yearning for things he cannot explain with simple math. A sexually starved stu- dent in search of desire and identity, the author wishes everything in his world could revolve around boys, gay this and boy that. And there’s no better place to achieve that than in Chelsea, New York City’s *fairyland of sex, cruising and excess, where Mendelsohn ends up moving and living half-time. In Chelsea, he dis- covers that gay identity itself is riddled in conflict and paradox, as the community argues for equal rights and civil rights while completely separating themselves from the heterosex- ual world. Mendelsohn also battles tough questions of per- sonal identity: “who am I?” and “what could I become?” The book explores the para- dox of a gay man’s desire for love and his love of desire. One conceivably desires to settle down with a partner, foster a family and be satisfied. But what about that cute guy cruising you from across the street? What if he is the man of your dreams4 and look at his package! The - search for middle ground in this paradox is tricky. Mendelsohn sug- gests that the sand is always shifting underneath, that identities are" always changing, that maybe we shouldn’t assume that we are strictly part of one and not the other. Mendelsohn brilliantly untangles these questions, and several others, using his per- sonal experience and thorough knowledge of classical Greek and Roman texts, such as the story of Narcissus, Ovid and’ Oedipus. Educated at Princeton, he is a master of these texts, and uses the ancient tales of tragedy and myth to cross-reference‘ his social commentary on gay life and his delicately personal journey from son to boy to_ hunk to scholar, and eventual- ly, to father figure. When Mendelsohn is asked to father the child of a close_ ‘ftieiiif, "he ‘i8fusé§f‘His feéilétfl commitment rears its ugly head. Yet when the friend bears a child, Daniel is there, sudden- ly thrust toward a more respon- sible, nurturing course as a male role model, which he ner- vously embraces. Suddenly this Chelsea playboy is now playing daddy, and he illus- trates his sensitivity toward the child beautifully. Here Mendelsohn absorbs some of the _child’s innocence, and describes him, well, innocent- ly: - “Since hewas about three months old, Nicholas has been a beautiful child. Until then he had the same rumpled and paradoxically old-looking face that many infants have, but when he turned three months, I became struck by his beauty. His head is large and round, except for a funny bump at the Daniel Mendelsohn The Elusive Embrace: Desire and the Riddle of Identity Vintage Books very back, which I always feel ‘for when cutting his hair, something I will not let anyone else do...” Mendelsohn’s vulnerability toward the child, his caring for him, encourages a discussion about gay men and their ability to escape the crazysexycruisy world and become successful parents, dispelling the myth that we are all inherently des- tined for singlehood. There are other surprises here. Mendelsohn goes into great detail discussing family myths, and while researching his family history, uncovers a dark family secret hidden for generations. The Elusive Embrace is rather thick with references at times. It walks the line of being too crowded with examples a“‘U.l1§Sl)§’;l2?«9l$§h‘i>‘Rl3§Si°a1= lit- erature. But overall, this is a courageous and insightful memoir. The thought, dedica- tion and knowledge thrown into this book are apparent, and it is probably a volume many men should have on their shelves. It is a deep exploration of our lives as gaymen, our struggle to understand who we are, know where we came from, and go _wherever we dream. David Grenier earned a degree in journalism from Saint Michaels College in 1997, co-founded College Street Magazine, and now works for Computer Games Magazine in Richmond, VT.V THAT BOOK STORE... and THAT ANTIQUE CENTER Used and Antiquarian Books, Antiques and Collectibles Multi-Dealer Shop Used and Out-of-Print Books, VT and NH Books, Post Cards, Paper Ephemera, Glass, Linens, Vintage Clothing, Coins, Primitives, Pottery and more... Something for Everyone! Usually...Mon-Sat 10:00-8:00, Sun 11:00-8:00 Railroad Street, St Johnsbury, VT 05819 802.748.1722 - email:tbs@plainfield.bypass.com http://www.allroutes.to/thatbookstore December" 2000 | Out in the Mountains ~| 25 ,, PHONIX RISING f spirited jewelry it gifts it gallery =a&e= 34 state streetllmontpelier, vt 05602 802.229.0522 ‘ M0“m—Sului(l0l ‘tum-ll ill“ Over 200,000 book, music, video & DVD titles Over 2,000 periodicals 30% discount on Borders best-sellers; Borders Best CD titles, $l2.99 and up Most Extensive Music selection in Burlington! °"d0y-Saruniay _ . . . . . am-ii Suntllw ‘him 99!“ Over 500 music listening stations to preview CD5 Sand pm al’ 90”!-9pm BORDERS?’ @ 29 (_Il-JURCH STREET MARKETPLACE ' BURLINGTON " 302-855-271 I Adult: Movies, Magazines, Toys, Latex. Lingerie, ViDeO EXPress FREE MEMBERSHIP!!! Gag Gifts, Cards and much more!!! SINGLES CONNECTION Sign in for single events, meetings 8. newsletters GAY B/ENTS Sign in for gay events. meetings & nevvslettiers SWINGERS‘ CLUB Sign in for gay events, meetings & newsletters M 0 N D HY Buy two movies. get the third free! TU'ElSDH‘YS Spend $ 200+, get a deluxe vacation for 2 - includes free deluxe hotel accommodation packages for 2! WE D N ESDAYS Buy 2 DVDs a" get the 4”" FREE TH U RSD FIYS Buy 3 magazine packs & get; the 4”‘ FREE 0 Fri., Sat., Sun., - Buy three movies, get the 4”‘ free Vlbeo sXpress 215 MAIN ST. WINOOSKI 854-365’! "A FUN PLACE TO SHOP FOR THE DISCIRIMINATING ADULT" You ARE one too! R.U.l.2? members receive our organization's newsletter From the Center, an R.U.l .2? bumper sticker, a membership card, and discounts on R.U.l.2? programs and events.’ Each month in O/TM, we will report our progress toward the goal of raising $3,000 in membership donations to benefit the community center protect. Call or write us todayland we'll send you a confidential membership invitation in the mail. And do_n’t forget, donations to R.U.1.2? are always tax-deductible! CONTACT US TODAY! Feel free to contact us anytime to find out more about the community center protect and how you can support our cause! So contact us about becoming a member of f R.U.1.2? Community Center, the organizing °t project that will establish a lesbian/gay/ ( bisexual/transgender and ally community center in Vermont. ° Now is the time to qive. lf vou make Q° a membership contribution this fall Samara Foundation of Vermont will DOUBLE your donation! R.U.1.2? Community Center PO Box 5883, Burlington, VT 05402-5883 email: thecenter@ru 1 2.org phone: 802.860-RU 1 2 www.ru12.org